_________________
Tuesday
3 April 2001

11 15 pm pdt [ what were guns invented for? ]

"If you go to racing school with me, will it just be to humor me?"

"I like shooting guns and driving fast."

"I'm glad you like driving fast. The idea that guns are really for killing animals or people is yucky to me."

"Well I obviously don't like killing animals. I like shooting at targets. Plus, I think guns were invented for killing people. Hmmm, do you think guns were invented for killing people or animals? I think people."

"That's a good question," he answered.

"That is a good question," I agreed.

Were guns invented for killing people or animals?

Which reminds me, I joined a high traffic mailing list for "exploring the intersections among teaching, learning, communication, community, and the new literacies." It seems to mostly consist of educators who are happy to use computers in their [mostly Englist and/or writing] classrooms. Anyway, the list members have gotten into a big session of bashing WebCT [Web Course Tools], which is a program for providing supposedly easy-to-use discussion lists, grade lists, chat rooms, etc. for class materials. So, some people are saying that people who use WebCT are supporting old pedagogies. And I quote,

...instead of moving the mainstream toward [a] more progressive pedagogy, these OLEs [Online Learning Environments] have moved in the direction of traditional pedagogies.

Here's where I have to confess that I felt the discussion was really pointless. They were having a very old argument about a rather new technology.

The argument is whether or not guns are inherently evil. Guns are made to shoot animals/people. But you could use a gun as a hammer or a doorstop. So the argument is whether the ill intent comes from the production of the gun or from the act of someone pulling the trigger.

And here we have all these academics arguing about whether this poor technology signifies a continuation of the old methods of teaching in and of itself or whether using this poor technology signifies a continuation of the old methods of teaching.

As I prefer to say, guns don't kill people; bullets kill people.

 

< yesterday     ~ month ~     tomorrow >
Rachel's Daily Diary   :::   the tip jar